The Allahabad High Court has upheld the government’s decision mandating graduation and recognised teacher training as the minimum qualifications for the post of assistant teacher in recognised junior high schools. The ruling reaffirms the state’s authority to ensure educational standards and training quality among teaching staff.
A two-judge bench comprising Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra passed the order while hearing a special appeal filed by the Uttar Pradesh government. The appeal challenged an earlier judgment delivered on September 24, 2024, which had struck down a clause in the government order prescribing these eligibility conditions.
Allahabad HC Sets Aside 2024 Single Judge Order
In 2024, a single judge bench had ruled in favour of petitioner Yashank Khandelwal and nine others, invalidating Clause 4 of the government order dated September 9, 2024. This clause had laid down that applicants for the assistant teacher position must hold a graduation degree from a UGC-recognised university along with a teacher training qualification approved by the state government or NCTE.
The petitioners had sought directions to allow candidates with an Intermediate Certificate Examination qualification to apply for the two-year Diploma in Elementary Education (D.El.Ed.) at District Institutes of Education and Training (DIETs). They also requested the court to quash the clause that required graduation for admission to the Basic Training Certificate (BTC) course.
Bench Upholds State’s Decision on Teacher Eligibility
The division bench observed that education laws and previous rules have consistently emphasised training and graduation as essential qualifications for teaching posts in basic schools. The judges noted that the State Government has prescribed graduation as a minimum qualification for entry into BTC and D.El.Ed. courses since 1998, aligning with the Rules of 1981 and standards set by the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE).
“The government’s provision cannot be termed arbitrary, as it maintains uniform standards in teacher training,” the bench stated. It concluded that the 2024 single judge order was inconsistent with these long-standing policies and hence, deserved to be set aside.
Court Dismisses Writ Petition
With this judgment, the High Court dismissed the writ petition filed by the respondents and upheld the validity of the 2024 government order. The ruling reinforces the requirement that only graduates with recognised teacher training are eligible for appointment as assistant teachers in recognised junior high schools.
The verdict is expected to bring clarity to teacher recruitment and training norms in Uttar Pradesh, ensuring that teaching positions continue to be filled by qualified and trained educators.
